Lakeland trustees cured an open meeting violation during a tense meeting Wednesday after board members discussed district policy in a group chat last month.

“This is how Marxism eats America … on(e) bite at a time,” trustee Jeff Brodhead texted to other board members on Oct. 22.

Trustee Dave Quimby responded, commiserating with Brodhead. Then trustee Randi Bain jumped in.

“I don’t know what this is about but it is inappropriate,” Bain said.

Brodhead argued that comments about board business were not doing board business. The group text is for communication with the board clerk about meeting arrangements, Bain said, not political debates.

Brodhead then clarified that he was upset about a new district policy.

The board approved Policy 4215 the night before. The policy restricts political campaigning on school property and is based on a similar policy in the Post Falls district. Bain had asked Lakeland’s policy committee to consider creating a similar policy over the summer to prevent disruptions to the school environment.

Brodhead argued at the October meeting that school property is the community’s property and that patrons should be able to use it, especially with limited places to inform the public.

“I’m concerned that we’re taking away the community’s ability to communicate things that are important to community members,” Brodhead said.

He argued people could be dealt with based on their behavior.

“We’ve become a nation where so many of our rights are being chopped away because somebody’s a bad actor,” he said.

Bain said the policy was about protecting students.

“I think that electioneering and campaigning on school property, especially when students are present, just increases the risk of something happening, and it’s not just to students but to school property,” Bain said ahead of the vote.

She noted that campaigns have impeded traffic in school parking lots in the past, despite being the required 250 feet away from the polling place.

Trustees Bain, Quimby and Michelle Thompson voted to approve the policy. Ramona Grissom and Brodhead voted no.

Thompson opened Wednesday’s meeting by reading a statement about the open meeting violation.

“We have a violation of open meeting law that we would like to cure. For the record, the board clerk communicates with the board of trustees through text communication to ensure the board has the same information regarding meeting reminders,” Thompson read. “This promotes consistency and uniformity as well as ensuring each trustee receives the same information.”

Lakeland’s history of open meeting issues

Lakeland cured another open meeting violation in July after trustees voted to extend the then-interim superintendent’s contract without properly placing the contract on the agenda.

Trustees made a similar move later in July but did not cure the possible violation.

EdNews filed a public records request for the messages in the Lakeland Trustee group chat dating back to August.

A review of the messages shows the chat was largely used for communication surrounding meeting planning and logistics. See the texts here.

Thompson cited the Idaho Code on deliberation before opening up discussion on the policy and violation.

“I believe I’ve said enough on the public record,” Brodhead eventually responded.

Thompson then opened up the conversation about the open meeting violation.

“I think that anytime anybody has something to say, this is the form and the format we say it in,” Grissom said, gesturing to the meeting room.

Thompson then asked Brodhead if he had questions for her about the policy.

“Can’t we have a meeting executive session?” Brodhead responded. “I can’t extrapolate the question.”

Thompson said she learned Brodhead had accused her of bringing the policy right before the Nov. 3 election. Brodhead confirmed he felt that way.

“I requested it in July,” Bain said. “And maybe if you’d have showed up to a policy committee meeting, you would have known that they’d been working on it since then.”

Thompson said the timing of the policy wasn’t purposeful and that the policy went through the proper process, including getting public comment.

“I have yelled this from the rooftop often. If anyone has a question of me, do please ask me,” Thompson said. “Don’t make assumptions and spread untruths when you haven’t even asked me.”

Grissom encouraged trustees to ask the clerk if they have questions about the law or policies. Brodhead thanked the clerk for providing guidance on open meeting laws after the incident.

“My apologies,” he said.

Watch the full meeting here:

Emma Epperly

Emma Epperly

Emma came to us from The Spokesman Review. She graduated from Washington State University with a B.A. in journalism and heads up our North Idaho Bureau.

Get EdNews in your inbox