Four times this year, the Idaho State Tax Commission denied public records requests seeking data on how many recipients of the state’s new private education tax credit were already attending private schools or homeschooling. 

In response to the requests — which included two from Idaho Education News — officials at the Tax Commission said that this data was “not being collected or reported on” through the Parental Choice Tax Credit program. Therefore, the requests were denied. 

So it was a surprise Friday when the agency released a report that included this statistic: Nearly 75% of tax credit recipients said on their applications that they had never attended an Idaho public school. 

One might logically conclude that students who weren’t previously attending a public school were previously enrolled in a private school or homeschooling, right? 

Sure, the 75% probably includes some preschoolers or kindergarteners starting school for the first time. It might also include some families who just moved here from another state and have never attended an Idaho school.

But surely most of the 9,162 students who answered “no” would fall under the category of previously attending a private school or homeschool.

Not so fast, says the Tax Commission. 

The agency only collected data on how many students were previously “enrolled in an Idaho public school,” Renee Eymann, senior public information officer, said Friday. But the records requests asked for data on recipients “previously enrolled in private schools.” 

“We didn’t collect this information on private schools,” Eymann said by email.  

So when EdNews asked for data on how many tax credit recipients “were previously enrolled in private or nonpublic schools,” as we did in April and July, we should have instead asked for data showing how many recipients “weren’t previously enrolled in a public school.”

Perhaps our records requests could have been more precise. Alternatively, officials at the Tax Commission could have clarified what data they were collecting, so members of the public would know what to ask for. 

EdNews first asked nearly a year ago what data from the tax credit application the agency would collect — beyond what was required by House Bill 93. The Tax Commission didn’t provide specifics, so our records requests became guesswork. 

The result: We guessed wrong, and our records requests were ruled out of bounds on a technicality.

Ryan Suppe

Ryan Suppe

Senior reporter Ryan Suppe covers education policy, focusing on K-12 schools. He previously reported on state politics, local government and business for newspapers in the Treasure Valley and Eastern Idaho. A Nevada native, Ryan enjoys golf, skiing and movies. Follow him on Bluesky @ryansuppe.bsky.social. Contact him at ryan@idahoednews.org

Get EdNews in your inbox