OPINION
Voices from the Idaho EdNews Community

After months of waiting, last week the Idaho State Tax Commission finally released information about which parents are receiving the $50 million in voucher money.

Surprise, surprise, the Tax Commission report says most of the money is going to families that earn more than double the income of the average Idahoan and students who have never attended public schools. 

The average family that received voucher money this year earned $178,000, more than double the $84,234 of the average Idaho family. This makes the voucher program a government handout for families who can already afford to send their kids to private schools.

Moreover, 75 percent of the families who took the money have never had their kids enrolled in a public school, even though advocates for the program promised that it would help students leave so-called “failing public schools” to attend private ones.

And of the 25 percent of families whose kids did attend a public school, only 4.6 percent were enrolled for an entire school year a year ago. 

Critics of the voucher program warned that it would mainly benefit families living in urban areas rather than in rural communities. As expected, two thirds of the voucher money went to families living in just three counties – Ada, Canyon, and Kootenai.

Furthermore, nearly 25 percent of the money went to only five private schools, most of them religious schools: Bishop Kelly High School in Boise, Cole Valley Christian in Meridian, Nampa Christian School, The Ambrose School in Meridian and Logos Classical Christian School in Moscow which is led by Christian Nationalist Doug Wilson.

Sen. Janie Ward-Engelking, a retired teacher, was one of the leading opponents of the voucher program and on Friday reacted to the Tax Commission report: “It’s hard enough for working parents to make ends meet without being asked to subsidize private school tuition for families who are better off than they are.”

Ward-Engelking said someone should “explain to a rural parent why their child’s school can’t afford another teacher, but the state can afford to help a well-off family pay private school tuition. That’s a pretty lousy deal for rural Idaho.”

Nothing in this report should be a surprise to Governor Brad Little or the legislators who voted to create the voucher program. They were warned that voucher programs across the country benefit the rich, and families that never sent their kids to public schools, and urban families over rural families. 

Still, Republican legislators, most of them rural, voted for vouchers and Governor Little signed it into law, even though 32,000 Idahoans contacted his office and asked him to veto the bill. 

Vouchers, which are unpopular among most citizens, was one of the major issues in the country during the recent mid-term election. The issue contributed to the election of Democratic governors and legislators in many Republican states which adopted vouchers.

In Texas, longtime Republican Governor Greg Abbott, the leading advocate for school vouchers in the Lone Star State, lost to a Democrat who made her reputation by opposing vouchers while serving in the Legislature. In Arizona, voters not only re-elected Democratic Governor Katie Hobbs by a comfortable margin but elected a Democratic majority in both houses of the Arizona Legislature for the first time since 1966. 

In Iowa and Ohio, where Republican governors and legislators have expanded voucher programs, voters elected a Democratic governor for the first time in years.

Unfortunately, in Idaho voters did not have a chance to weigh in on the voucher issue with accurate information about who it benefits. As a result, only one of the 62 Republican legislators who voted for the voucher bill lost their seat in the recent election. You cannot blame voters – they didn’t have the information on which to base their votes. 

For months reporters asked the Tax Commission to release information about who is receiving the voucher money, but every time the commission said it didn’t have the information or didn’t have to release the information. It’s no coincidence that the Commission finally released the data just days after the mid-term election and after Governor Little and the lawmakers who voted for the program were safely re-elected.

It would be laughable, if it were not so cynical, that Governor Little now claims that “transparency and accountability are important to ensuring the Parental Tax Credit works as intended and serves Idaho families well.”

Of course, “transparency” loses much of its value when the information is released after candidates are safely re-elected and “accountability” loses all its value when voters are not given the information to decide which officeholders are worthy or unworthy of their support. 

Claiming that he “went above and beyond to provide as much information and data as possible” about the voucher program, Little says the data can now be used to “evaluate the effectiveness” of the program and “identify opportunities for improvement and ensure it continues to serve Idahoans well.”

“Continues to serve Idahoans well?”

That sounds like a politician who could have avoided the hurricane if he had listened to the thousands of Idahoans who took the time to tell him to kill the voucher bill and a politician who now vows to clean up the mess he created. Let’s hope that the governor is more sincere about the cleanup than he was about asking for – and then ignoring – thousands of citizens before the storm. 

If he is sincere, Little could start by asking the Legislature in his State of the State address next January to repeal the voucher program because it is not working for most Idaho citizens. The wealthy families who have received the money will be just fine. 

He could ask the Legislature to repeal the program because it benefits mainly Idahoans who have never sent their kids to public schools. 

He could ask the Legislature to repeal the program because it costs $50 million, money that could go to help fund Idaho’s underfunded public schools where most Idahoans – especially working-class families – send their kids. 

He could ask the Legislature to repeal the program because it overwhelmingly serves urban counties at the expense of Idaho’s rural counties. 

He could ask the Legislature to repeal the program because it violates the Idaho Constitution’s ban on using taxpayer dollars to fund religious schools, the primary beneficiaries of vouchers.

And he could tell the Legislature to repeal the program because it is an honest thing to do now that we truly know who benefits from it and who doesn’t. 

Unfortunately, the historical record shows that the governor will not do any of these things, and the Legislature won’t correct its mistake. The voucher program will continue for the next two years and even get expanded.

But in two years, armed with the truth, Idaho voters will have a chance to decide who is working in the best interest of their school children and who is not. 

Rod Gramer is an Idaho native, longtime journalist, and advocate for public education.

Rod Gramer

Get EdNews in your inbox

Weekly round up every Friday