The kindergarteners who walked into Shoshone Elementary this fall struggled to hold a pencil, may not know any letters or even which way to hold a book.
That’s not what teachers are used to.
“Those pre-reading skills, that often students came with, we are seeing that they are not coming to school with,” Principal Kelly Wilkins said.
Only 28% of kindergarteners in Shoshone were reading at or above grade level, according to the Idaho Reading Indicator, a standardized test given in September to students in grades K-3. That’s far below the statewide proficiency of 43.9%.
For years, Idaho’s fall kindergarten proficiency improved from 40.8% in 2021 to 53.1% in 2024. Then last year, the state released a new version of the exam through test provider Amira. The old IRI had students select the correct answer from a variety of choices, while on the new exam students respond out loud to their device.
“I think that students coming into kindergarten are just not as prepared for working with computers and headphones and early literacy skills,” said Kacy Proctor, IRI program manager at the Idaho Department of Education.
Kindergarteners were 44% proficient or better last fall. That statewide score came with a host of issues as schools worked out the kinks with the new exam. For example, in Boundary County, just 11% of kindergarteners scored proficient after cases on the iPads used for the exam muffled student responses.
The testing window was also pushed back to October so educators could have more time to learn the new software. This fall, students returned to taking the exam in September, just weeks into the school year. The fall test serves as a baseline for growth over the school year and a look at summer learning loss.
Learn more about this fall’s statewide reading proficiency here.
In Shoshone, Wilkins noticed a shift since the COVID-19 pandemic in students being less ready for kindergarten. It’s especially pronounced in the small rural district that serves 470 students in grades K-12, with 80% of students identified as low income.
Many students are also learning English for the first time at school, she added. There are few daycare providers in the area, and even federally funded Head Start can be sporadic as the program struggles to find and retain employees.
Wilkins is in the midst of applying for a grant to start what she calls a cradle-to-kindergarten program that would focus on language acquisition, fine motor activities, and bringing in experts like doctors and nutritionists to educate parents.
“Just trying to figure out how we can help them help their kids,” Wilkins said.
American Falls toddlers have benefited from a similar program for the last five years. Superintendent Randy Jensen started a preschool push in 2019 along with a campaign called “Read Talk Play,” which encouraged parents to engage in key developmental activities with their children.
The district now benefits from a federal community schools grant, administered through United Way. Private preschools in the area benefit by attending district trainings and using similar curriculum to what the district expects in kindergarten, said Jeff Blauer, principal at Hillcrest Elementary.
Still, kindergarten reading proficiency was far below the state level on the IRI at 27.5% this fall.
Blauer said there are a variety of reasons for the low scores, including just how early the test is given, but students improve rapidly after more instruction. This month, the kindergarten proficiency rate was 71%.
The district has focused on more explicit phonics instruction and more paraprofessionals intervening early for struggling students, who can be identified early due to the collaboration with area preschools, he said.
“We’ve seen tremendous improvement,” he said.
Other districts also see that jump in proficiency by November. In the Lake Pend Oreille School District, 44.4%% of kindergarteners were proficient on the IRI.
“Our kindergarteners are young and still learning the basics of being in a classroom, from sitting in chairs to holding pencils. At the same time, we’re asking them to complete a literacy assessment on a touchscreen Chromebook, something some have never used before, let alone spoken into,” said Shelby Struhs, community relations coordinator with the district. “We see a sharp increase in kindergarten literacy scores by November.”
Sometimes an individual group of students can exceed expectations, Struhs noted. Last fall, Lake Pend Oreille had the highest kindergarten proficiency statewide, and this year those same students were far above average with 72.5% proficiency, even beating out the second graders in their own district who were 64% proficient.
Idaho Superintendent of Public Instruction Debbie Critchfield kicked off her plan to improve school preparedness with The Readiness Zone Summit last month.
The virtual event brought in national experts on school readiness and reading. The summit focused on first grade, in part because Idaho districts are not required to offer full-day kindergarten. Last school year, 22 school districts and charters only offered half-day kindergarten. The rest of the 173 districts or charters that have the grade level offer kindergarteners a full day.
Critchfield hoped the summit would encourage local leaders to be innovative and consider new approaches even without state funds.
“Some of the folks that you’re going to hear from today that have really changed my thinking on how we approach this,” Critchfield said. “We don’t wait for money. We don’t wait for some silver bullet to come into Idaho and say this is the magical thing that will get our kids there.”
