A Boise State University Ph.D. student filed a tort claim alleging the university refused to assemble the mandatory dissertation committee required to finish his degree.
Jeffrey Morgan is seeking damages of at least $1.5 million, according to the Oct. 15 claim.
The university declined to comment on the claim, through Stephany Galbreaith, director of media relations.
Morgan finished all coursework for his Ph.D. in Boise State’s Public Policy and Administration Program with a 4.0 GPA, according to the claim. As he moved toward his final step — completing his dissertation — the university rejected his proposal and entered an F grade.
Morgan appealed the grade this spring. On April 29, the university acknowledged programmatic failures led to the failing grade and wiped it from his transcript, according to the claim.
Interim program director Jaclyn Kettler wrote in an April 22 letter to the university’s registrar that “some program-level issues contributed to his challenges” with the course. The university hadn’t offered a key course on developing dissertation proposals when Morgan needed it because of a shortage of faculty available to teach it, Kettler wrote.
“For reasons completely outside of his control, he was in a disadvantaged position in terms of his proposal development — making it harder to be successful in the course,” Kettler wrote.
Program leadership and faculty turnover also contributed to the issue, Kettler said. Morgan needed to find a new dissertation chair and committee, which was “quite challenging” due to the number of faculty retiring or leaving the university.
On April 30, the registrar approved removing the course from Morgan’s transcript, according to an email attached to the tort claim.
The university is in the midst of merging the College of Education and School of Public Service. The merger, which will happen over the course of two years, won’t impact students, Andrew Finstuen, the interim dean, said this spring. The university did not respond to questions about the Public Policy and Administration PhD program.
Morgan’s claim states that the university offered a transfer option that isn’t viable because Morgan would lose all the credits he already completed in the doctoral program.
“Rather than correcting the structural issue by appointing a functional committee, the university administration left Claimant in a permanent academic blockade, offering only a disingenuous “transfer” that nullified years of labor and passing of comprehensive exams,” the claim reads.
Morgan estimates lost wages of $1.5 million ($60,000 per year for 25 years as a non-tenure-track faculty member). He also estimates $15,000 in student loan-related losses.
