The debate over expanding (or killing) Idaho’s private school tax credit entered a new stage Friday — when the Idaho State Tax Commission released a damning and detailed trove of data on the $50 million program.
The commission report handed a lot of ammunition to opponents of the Idaho Parental Choice Tax Credit. The critics probably don’t have the political juice to repeal the program. However, they have some new and hard numbers on their side.
- The tax credits largely benefitted wealthier families. The average adjusted gross income for tax credit recipients came in at $178,000.
- The credits largely benefitted families who were already outside the public school system. Only 25% of the tax credits supported students who were leaving a public school — suggesting that a lot of money went to parents who were already homeschooling their children, or sending their kids to private school.
- The credits largely benefitted families in urban and suburban Idaho. The Tax Commission ranked applications by legislative district (and remember, legislative districts are drawn up to have more or less the same populations). Six of the top 10 districts are in Ada or Canyon counties; two more take in pieces of Kootenai County.
These three data points are crucial. They tie straight into the debate over the tax credits — which became law in 2025, with the passage of House Bill 93.
Supporters said the $5,000 to $7,500 credits would open education options to families who could not otherwise afford to leave the public school system. The credits, they said, were about providing access and supporting choice.
When the Tax Commission data came out Friday — and supporters and opponents alike went straight into the spin cycle — the advocates latched onto numbers supporting their version of the narrative.
They pointed to Tax Commission numbers from May: About 45% of tax credit recipients had household incomes at or below 300% of the federal poverty level (now $99,000 a year for a family of four).
In a kind of glass-quarter-full argument, the pro-tax credit Mountain States Policy Center said Friday, “3,092 awarded students — 25.3% — had previously attended public school.”
Mountain States also pointed out that the tax credits made their way into households in each of Idaho’s 35 legislative districts. “The data is even more surprising given that opponents claimed there were no choice options available in rural areas,” wrote Chris Cargill, Mountain States’ president, in a Sunday post defending the tax credit and criticizing news coverage of the Tax Commission’s data drop.
This is all factually accurate. Some lower-income families took advantage of the credit. Some used the money to move their children out of public schools. Some explored learning options in rural communities with limited private school options. Any of the above. All of the above.
However, statistics don’t just show the exceptions to the rule. They also lay out the contours of the rule itself.
So, yes, residents of legislative District 34, Madison County, collected a little more than $200,000 in tax credits. But at the same time, residents in District 20, in and around Meridian, collected close to $3.6 million. Madison County is the exception. Meridian is the rule, along with similar urban and suburban districts.
The Tax Commission presented a statistical aggregate. The prototypical tax credit recipients live in a six-figure household, most likely reside in or near a population center, and quite possibly they had their kids in private school long before House Bill 93 came along. That’s the prototype. And it’s an inconvenient one for supporters of the program.
Which leads us to the 2027 legislative session.
Saying the Tax Commission’s numbers illustrate a “rousing success,” Mountain States pounded away at expansion last week. Pumping an additional $25 million into the program would serve an additional 6,100 students. Doubling down, adding $50 million to the kitty, would serve an additional 12,200 students.
Mountain States’ math checks out. But does Idaho have that kind of money — and do private school choice backers have the votes?
Idaho’s fiscal picture was far different in 2025, when HB 93 became law. While creating a $50 million private education tax credit program, the Legislature also increased general fund budgets for state agencies by $357 million — with $102.8 million going to public schools. Gov. Brad Little and the Legislature cut most agency budgets in 2026, leaving K-12 mostly unscathed, and Little has asked agencies to hold the line on spending requests for 2027.
In the K-12 space, state superintendent Debbie Critchfield has made only one line item request for 2027-28: a $20 million increase in discretionary spending. A $25 million or $50 million increase in education tax credits would be inevitably, and fairly, judged against public school spending decisions.
It’s also important to remember that HB 93 didn’t exactly sail through the Legislature. It passed the House by a 42-28 vote and passed the Senate by a closer 20-15 margin. But the 2027 Legislature is likely to be more moderate than the 2025 model: Centrists picked up some ground in the May Republican primary, and Democrats added six seats in November.
Supporters of expanding the tax credit program already faced a battle. The Tax Commission’s data is unlikely to win them many converts.
The next battle over private school choice began with some big talk from both sides. While Mountain States used the moment to press for expansion, Idaho Education Association President Peggy Hoy didn’t mince any words either. “Not one more cent of Idahoans’ hard-earned tax dollars should go to vouchers,” she said. “In fact, this failed experiment should be repealed.”
In the end, there’s a decent chance that nothing changes in 2027. No expansion. No repeal. But ample disagreement.
Senior reporter Kevin Richert writes a weekly analysis on education policy and education politics.
