Former Timberline students sue over expulsions related to online comments

Former students at Boise’s Timberline High School have filed a federal lawsuit, saying they were unfairly expelled amidst a public outcry over threatening online comments.

The comments on the Snapchat social media platform — a graphic thread that discussed raping and killing a female student — were “crude and distasteful,” the former Timberline football players’ attorneys acknowledge in the lawsuit. But the thread was not “a serious expression of an intent to commit violence,” according to the lawsuit.

Meanwhile, the attorneys said, district leaders had already publicly condemned the online comments, promising to bring the students to justice.

“Plaintiffs were denied a meaningful opportunity to present their defenses to the allegations before the decision was made to punish them,” according to the lawsuit, filed Nov. 6 in U.S. District Court in Boise.

The lawsuit came barely a month after the content of the social media thread went public — prompting an Oct. 3 online petition calling for immediate disciplinary action and an Oct. 7 student walkout at Timberline. Before the walkout, district officials canceled or postponed Homecoming activities at Timberline, saying the firestorm over the online thread posed a threat to safety.

The lawsuit says district and school officials quickly suspended the four players involved in the “Gameday lunch” Snapchat thread. The suspensions stretched for 17 days, and according to the lawsuit, the players were not given a chance to be heard.

Near the end of the 17-day suspensions, according to the lawsuit, Timberline Principal Chad Wright recommended removing the students from school, assigning them to Boise Alternative to Suspension and Expulsion school or Boise Online School for fall semester, or the remainder of the year. Three of the four students are assigned to online school for the semester or the school year, and a fourth is under a tutoring plan.

The district held hearings before permanently removing the students from Timberline, the lawsuit said, but the students were not given adequate time to prepare a defense. Ultimately, the students were reassigned not because of their online comments but because of “the public’s reaction to those communications and the disruption it caused,” the lawsuit said.

The lawsuit does not identify the students by name — only as John Does Nos. 1 through 4. One plaintiff, identified only as Jane Roe, is the legal guardian of John Doe No. 4.

The lawsuit names five Boise school administrators as defendants: Superintendent Wendy Johnson; Deputy Superintendent Nick Smith; Shelley Bonds, the area director for Timberline and neighboring schools; Jason Hutchinson, the Borah area director who oversaw the students’ disciplinary hearings; and Wright.

District spokesman Dan Hollar declined comment on the lawsuit Tuesday.

A criminal investigation is ongoing.

“(The Boise Police Department) has reviewed the evidence currently available and will continue to evaluate additional evidence as it is received from the social media platforms,” spokeswoman Haley Kramer said in an email Tuesday. “It is anticipated that it will take time to receive and evaluate this additional evidence and interview additional witnesses based on that new information.”

More reading: Click here for coverage from the Idaho Statesman, which first reported on the lawsuit.

Kevin Richert

Kevin Richert

Senior reporter and blogger Kevin Richert specializes in education politics and education policy. He has more than 40 years of experience in Idaho journalism, and extensive experience covering state politics and the Legislature. He is a frequent guest on "Idaho Reports" on Idaho Public Television. He can be reached at krichert@idahoednews.org

Get EdNews in your inbox