OPINION
Voices from the Idaho EdNews Community

On January 1, 2027, Idaho families and students will gain access to one of the most exciting educational opportunities in a generation. Thanks to the new federal scholarship tax credit (FSTC), Idaho taxpayers will be able to direct up to $1,700 of their federal income taxes toward supporting students and schools in their own communities. Money that otherwise would go to Washington, DC stays in Idaho to support our schools and families.

This will unlock new resources for student learning, expand educational opportunities, and strengthen Idaho public schools—all at no net cost to participating taxpayers or the state, as we previously wrote.

The federal scholarship tax credit is fundamentally different from Idaho’s Parental Choice Tax Credit. While Idaho’s program exclusively benefits private school and homeschool families, the FSTC supports students in public, public charter, and private schools. Understandably, the two programs have caused some confusion, compounded by recent headlines surrounding an Idaho Tax Commission report on the state program. But the distinctions are significant: the programs differ in how they are funded, who benefits, and how the funds can be used.

For starters, the FSTC applies to federal taxes, while Idaho’s Parental Choice Tax Credit applies to state taxes. Passed by the Idaho Legislature in 2024, the state credit took effect this year. The federal program, meanwhile, launches January 1, 2027, when taxpayers can begin making qualifying donations and claim their credits when filing federal taxes in 2028 and beyond.

The funding mechanisms also differ significantly. Idaho’s tax credit is funded by a $50 million state appropriation, while the federal program relies entirely on individual and voluntary taxpayer donations to scholarship granting organizations. Donors receive a federal tax credit for their contributions, and the total scholarship funding available to students depends on how many taxpayers choose to participate each year, effectively making individual Idaho taxpayers philanthropists for schools and students they want to support.

The federal tax credit can and will benefit public school students. In fact, public school is where the lion’s share of the impact will be because most Idaho students attend a public school! Once donations are received and scholarships awarded, students can receive support without waiting for donors to claim their federal tax credits.

From speaking with our colleagues across the country, we know that Idaho and Bluum SGO are leaders in putting the federal scholarship tax credit to work for all students and school types. But we know that the recent proliferation of school choice programs nationwide and in Idaho make the landscape confusing for parents, taxpayers and educators in general. To maximize the impact of the federal tax credit program for Idaho’s students, we will continue to clarify how the programs differ and show how public-school students benefit from this opportunity to empower taxpayers and families alike.

Program Differences At A Glance

Idaho Parental Choice Tax Credit Federal scholarship tax credit (FSTC)
Who Benefits A student whose parent claims the credit on their Idaho tax return after making a qualified purchase (like paying for private school tuition) A student whose family applies to a scholarship granting organization (SGO) and receives a scholarship
Amount Parents get up to a $5,000 credit per student, or $7,500 with a qualifying disability, against their Idaho income tax Donors get a credit against their federal taxes up to $1,700, and scholarship size for students is not capped
Who is Eligible Private school and homeschool students Traditional public, public charter, and private school students
Income Limit None, though the intent is to prioritize families at or below 300% of the federal poverty level Students at or below 300% of area median income (about 90% of Idaho families)
Allowable Expenses Tuition, tutoring, transportation, exam fees and learning opportunities. In the initial reporting year, 93.5% went to private school tuition Broad set of potential uses, including tutoring, after-school and summer enrichment, zero-hour or fifth-day learning opportunities, and tuition
Funding $50 million cap per year through a state appropriation approved by the Idaho legislature Individual donor contributions to SGOs and designate the districts or school where a student will benefit, with no cap on total giving and no impact on the state budget
Who has benefited so far Average family income of $178,000, with 4.3% of students having attended public school in the past Launches January 1, 2027, and public school students will likely be the largest group of beneficiaries

Terry Ryan is the Chief Executive Officer and Duncan Robb is the Chief Strategy Officer at BLUUM Idaho. 

Duncan Robb and Terry Ryan

Get EdNews in your inbox

Weekly round up every Friday